Showing posts with label Books and Studies. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Books and Studies. Show all posts

Switzerland: Religious freedom in prison

Switzerland: Religious freedom in prison

Via WRS:

Religious freedom is generally respected in Swiss prisons, according to a study released on Wednesday in Bern by the National Fund for Scientific Research.

Warsaw: Muslims in Europe - a wealth of diversity or a source of conflict?

Warsaw: Muslims in Europe - a wealth of diversity or a source of conflict?

The problem with such conferences is that the answer is already obvious.

Via PR:
A two day conference devoted to Muslims in Europe is being held in Warsaw, organized by the European Islamic Institute at Warsaw University.

(...)

A key element of the “Muslims in Europe- a wealth of diversity or a source of conflict?” conference aims to show that Islam should not be identified with terrorism.

“Terrorism can be found in many places and perpetrated by those from all religions. It is vital that we refrain from identifying it exclusively with Islam,” said Anna Parzymies from the Islamic Centre in Warsaw.

(more)

Germany: 'Germany is destroying itself'

Germany: 'Germany is destroying itself'

'Germany is destroying itself -
how we're jeopardizing our country'

Book Review: Shall the Religious Inherit the Earth?

Book Review: Shall the Religious Inherit the Earth?

Shall the Religious Inherit the Earth?: Demography and Politics in the Twenty-First Century by Eric Kaufmann


Via The Observer, Kenan Malik's review:


Europe, 2020. The Islamists have stormed to power across the continent. Every French woman is forced to be veiled. Holland's gay clubs have been relocated to San Francisco.


(...)


Book Review: The Future of Islam

Book Review: The Future of Islam

LibertyPhile posted a review of The Future of Islam by John L. Esposito. I have not yet read the book, but one point based on this review: Anybody who brings radicals such as Qaradawi and Ramadan as exemplary reformers, should also deal with the fact that they continuously threaten Europe and the Western World with a 'Muslim takeover'. In fact, by claiming they are moderates, Esposito encourages 'Islamophobia' and the idea that there are no real moderate Muslims.

I bring here an excerpt:

(4) Muslims in the West

Esposito’s treatment of Muslims in the West is totally inadequate. We get the standard condemnation of hate preachers but what we mainly get is special pleading and an exiguous failure to understand the depth of the problem and to suggest any solutions.


UK: More on the British Social Attitudes study

UK: More on the British Social Attitudes study


Via LibertyPhile, data and analysis of the recent British Social Attitudes study. LibertyPhile also has an analysis of the Gallup Coexist Study 2009: Gallup Coexist Study 2009 – The Headlines You Didn’t See!


It's interesting to note, in the question below, that Muslims and "Deeply religious" have very similar scores. Those are the only two groups towards which more people feel 'cool' than 'warm'. The difference being -2 for 'deeply religious' and -11 for Muslims.


What the British think of religion and Muslims




(...)


(3) What people think of Muslims


Q. I’d like to get your feelings towards a number of different ethnic and religious groups.


I’ll read the name of a group and I’d like you to rate that group using something we call the feeling thermometer. Ratings between 50 degrees and 100 degrees mean that you feel favourable and warm toward the group.



Ratings between 0 degrees and 50 degrees mean that you don’t feel favourable and don’t care too much for that group. You would rate the group at the 50-degree mark if you don’t feel particularly warm or cold towards the group. Feel free to use the entire extent of the scale. [Source Table 4.13 – p79]



Feelings towards different religious groups in Britain - % Who rate:


Religious group Cool (0-49) Neutral (50) Warm (51-100)


No religion: Cool - 8; Neutral - 49; Warm - 40
[ + 32 ]

Protestants:
Cool - 6; Neutral - 44; Warm - 47 [ +41 ]

Catholics
: Cool - 9; Neutral - 43; Warm - 45 [ +36 ]

Jews: Cool - 13; Neutral - 47; Warm - 36 [ +23 ]

Buddhists
: Cool - 15; Neutral - 45; Warm - 35 [ +20 ]

Deeply religious
: Cool - 29; Neutral - 41; Warm - 27 [ -2 ]

Muslims
: Cool - 34; Neutral - 40; Warm - 23 [ -11 ]

(more)


See also: UK: Islam seen as threat to social cohesion

National identification among Muslims

National identification among Muslims

Update 2: Fixed typo.

Update: Forgot to post this..

"Most important national values of living in the country"

There's generally agreement among Muslims and non-Muslims on the various values, but they diverge on the following:

Respect for the law - Muslims 64.3%, non-Muslims 54.0%
Tolerance towards others - Muslims 37.4%, non-Muslims 49.9%
Freedom of speech and expression - Muslims 49.5%, non-Muslims 61.5%
Respect for all faiths - Muslims 51.6%, non-Muslims 29.1%

It's interesting that non-Muslims put an emphasis on tolerance, while Muslims put an emphasis on respect.

-------------

The Open Society Institute (OSI) recently published their study of Muslims in Europe, focusing on 11 cities. Thank you to all those who tipped me on it. I put off posting about it, since I intended to sit down and read it. I haven't gotten around to studying it, yet, but since I don't know when that will happen.. I've decided to go with skimming it for now and focusing on the big news stories.

The published study is actually an overview. OSI will be publishing more detailed studies of every city in the upcoming few years.

According to LibertyPhile, the study also suffers from various problems, such as a very small sample size.


The one question in the study that got a lot of attention was "Do you see yourself as [British, French etc.]?"

Muslims - 49.0% Yes, 51.0% No
Non-Muslims - 77.1% Yes, 22.9% No

But this one is just as important: "Do most other people in this country see you as [British, French, etc.]?"

Muslims - 24.5% Yes, 75.5% No
Non-Muslims - 74.8% Yes, 25.2% No


Half of the European Muslims who were interviewed see themselves as nationals, but just a quarter think others see them this way. This breaks down to just over two-thirds of European-born Muslims and just under 40% of foreign-born Muslims.

The breakdown by city/country is quite interesting:

UK: Leicester - 82%, London - 72% (40% feel they're seen as nationals)

Netherlands: Amsterdam - 59%, Rotterdam - 43%

France: Marseille - 58%, Paris - 41% [elsewhere the report says 58% for Paris, I don't know which one is the typo]

Belgium: Antwerp - 55%

Sweden: Stockholm - 41%

Denmark: Copenhagen - 40%

Germany: Berlin - 25%, Hamburg - 22% (11% feel they're seen as nationals)

A majority of European-born Muslims in every city expressed national identification, except for Berlin (35%) and Hamburg (46%). Since this is only an overview, there's no breakdown for the "do others see you as a national" question. The overview doesn't show us the answers to the question "Do you want to be seen by others as [British, French, etc.]?" either.

There's a significant difference between Amsterdam and Rotterdam (16 point gap), and between Marseille and Paris (17 points). It's hard to draw conclusions on what this means.

It would have been interesting if OSI would have asked the non-Muslims whether they think Muslims are nationals. For example, British Muslims feel by far most British, which of course made the headlines. On the other hand, a recent poll also shows that 52% of the British feel their country is deeply divided along religious lines. As it, we're left with just the Muslim side of things, and even there there's a significant gap between how people see themselves and how they feel they're seen by others.

It is also interesting to note that 'British' is not really an ethnic term, and most Brits would describe themselves as English and not as British. 55% of Antwerp Muslims said they felt 'national', but we don't know whether the question asked about nationality (Belgian) or ethnicity (Flemish).

With Amsterdam being an exception, only a minority of Muslims said they felt 'national' in the countries where ethnicity and nationality are intertwined (Netherlands, Sweden, Denmark, Germany). And unsurprisingly, except for France and the UK, more Muslims said they felt a sense of belonging to their country than national identification. As one German Muslim explained: "Being German means ethnicity, that's why I can't be German, but I can be a German citizen."


"What is the main barrier to being [British, French, etc.]?"

Muslims - Not speaking the language (21%), other (26.8%), ethnicity (20.8%)
Non-Muslims- not speaking the language (34.3%), other (24.1%), ethnicity (13%)

OSI's conclusion is that speaking the language is the most important thing. But I'm not really sure that's the right conclusion here. In fact, 66% of non-Muslims didn't rate that as the main barrier. Besides which, 33% of Muslims and 35% of non-Muslims did not answer the question ('none of these', 'don't know', 'other').

See here for more on the study.

Sweden: Self-segregation isn't a bad thing, says study

Sweden: Self-segregation isn't a bad thing, says study


Segregation isn't necessarily a bad thing, according to a new report critical of policies which try to control where immigrants and refugees settle in Sweden.


“Closeness to fellow countrymen can actually be positive, especially if the group has a relatively strong socioeconomic position,” write economists Oskar Nordström Skans and Olof Ã…slund in an article published in the Dagens Nyheter (DN) newspaper.



In their presentation of the 2009 report on welfare by the Swedish Centre for Business and Policy Studies (SNS), the authors point out that there is no research to suggest the ethnic makeup of people in one’s surroundings have a decisive role in how well an individual integrates into the labour market or in school.



While Sweden's current placement system, based on a strategy of spreading refugees to various locations around the country and providing incentives to move to regions with fewer immigrants, does reduce housing market discrimination, it also makes it harder for immigrants to enter the labour market, according to Skans and Ã…slund.



“Our conclusion from this review is that a policy which aims to control immigrants’ residency patterns is wrong,” they write.


The authors suggest instead that politicians should focus on the underlying problems such as long-term unemployment and poverty in large immigrant communities.


Skans and Ã…slund add that it is “self-evident” that immigrants who come to Sweden should live by the same obligations and responsibilities as others when it comes to abiding by Swedish law.


“But with that it follows as well, in our opinion, that society ought to treat those who immigrate as equal members of society with the same rights as others,” they write.


(more)


Source: The Local (English)

Christopher Caldwell on the Colbert Report

Christopher Caldwell on the Colbert Report

"[Islam] is just as influential a religion in Europe as Christianity"


The Colbert ReportMon - Thurs 11:30pm / 10:30c
Christopher Caldwell
www.colbertnation.com
Colbert Report Full Episodes

Study: Conflicts over Mosques in Europe

Study: Conflicts over Mosques in Europe

The Network of European Foundations published a new study: Conflicts over Mosques in Europe (PDF), by Stefano Allievi.

Allievi prepared a chart of the estimated number of mosques in Europe (click the image to enlarge):


It's interesting to note that the Netherlands seems to be the one with the most purpose-built mosques (aside from Bosnia). Far more than Italy and Spain, which are estimated to have about the same number of Muslims, and proportionally more than the highest estimate for the UK.

The NEFIC published two additional studies, which deal with religions in general, and bring up issues also related to Islam: Religion and Healthcare in the European Union (PDF), by Dimitrina Petrova and Teaching about Religions in European School Systems (PDF), by Luce Pépin

UK: Contextualising Islam In Britain report

UK: Contextualising Islam In Britain report


If both Muslims and non-Muslims 'misunderstand' terms like 'Shariah' and 'Jihad' then it's not really an issue of 'misinterpretation'. If both speaker and listener agree on a term, then it means exactly what they agree it to mean. Having a passer-by start to argue with them that it really means something else is pointless.

But, if these researchers really think that Jihad means self-reform and active citizenship, then it is only logical that they should urge all British Muslim to strive for Jihad. Why does that sound ridiculous?


----------
A report which explores the philosophical and theological perspectives on what it means to be a Muslim in Britain today has been published.
The study, entitled Contextualising Islam in Britain: Exploratory Perspectives, is being launched today (Tuesday, October 6th), and can be downloaded at (http://www.cis.cam.ac.uk/CIBP.html).

It marks the culmination of a nine month research project which was hosted by the University of Cambridge in association with the Universities of Exeter and Westminster.
A total of 26 Muslim scholars, academics and activists representing a diverse spectrum of views from Muslim communities in the UK took part in discussions about what it means to live as a Muslim in modern Britain. The report covers a wide range of issues including secularism, democracy, Shariah law, human rights and citizenship.

The report presents the group's conclusions and aims to act as the basis for a wider discussion with other Muslim leaders and communities around the UK. In time, it is hoped that this will lead to the development of a virtual "House of Wisdom", providing space for discussion among both Muslims and non-Muslims on how Islam should function in modern Britain and contribute to wider society.



(..)


Despite its exploratory nature, the report puts forward conclusions concerning a number of key areas.
The authors argue, for example, that a secular British state provides many benefits for British Muslims, not least by allowing Islam to be practised freely in an atmosphere of respect, security and dignity.

The group agreed that Muslims should assert and teach what they see to be the truth of their faith, but also recognise the existence of different religions and the right of others to do the same. Their study urges Muslims to identify shared values between Islam and other world views, pointing out the Qu'ran's emphasis on qualities such as good neighbourliness, charity, hospitality and non-aggression.

The report also redefines a number of terms which the authors believe have been misinterpreted. It notes, for example, that both Muslims and non-Muslims often have "skewed understanding of the term Shari'ah, which conjures up images of floggings and beheadings."

In fact, it stresses, Shari'ah is a way of life based on an ethical code that emphasises dignity, equality and justice for all. Islam, it says, teaches the equality of all human beings regardless of gender.

Similarly, the study notes that "jihad" in its true sense refers to active citizenship, and is meant to encourage Muslims to strive for social justice, fight against poverty and make efforts to reform themselves.

In some, clearly defined, cases, it can also mean the legitimate use of force in self-defence. The authors add, however: "It is important to stress that Islam is opposed to all forms of terrorism, regardless of who sponsors them. While all legal systems recognise self-defence as a legitimate rationale for the use of force, it is clear that foreign conflicts cannot justify violence in Britain."

Finally, the report says that Muslims have a responsibility to be active citizens and engage with society in a positive way. Political engagement is described as an obligation for Muslim citizens and voting is to be encouraged. This can, however, also involve questioning and challenging the state when it fails to uphold principles of justice.

(more)


Source: University of Cambridge

Book review: Reflections on the Revolution in Europe

Book review: Reflections on the Revolution in Europe

Reflections on the Revolution in Europe: Immigration, Islam and the West, by Christopher Caldwell.

To buy the book: Reflections on the Revolution In Europe: Immigration, Islam, and the West


The book is divided into three sections, one each for Immigration, Islam and the West. Generally speaking, the 'immigration' section is devoted to a scathing criticism of the arguments used to justify mass immigration. The 'Islam' section looks at the problematics of Muslims in Europe, and 'The West' section looks at how Europe is dealing with this immigration.

A small gripe: The book has end-notes which give background and sources for some of the quotes and anecdotes. Instead of having pointers to the end-notes, they're simply listed by page number and partial quote from the original page. I can see the advantages, but I didn't realize they existed until I was halfway through the book.

'Reflections on the Revolution' is a very thought provoking book. I'll try to summarize the points I found most interesting together with my take on them. Some issues I've been thinking over for a while, some I've just started considering now, so this is really a work in progress.


US vs. Europe

I don't intend to repeat all of Caldwell's arguments against mass immigration. In the 1960s and 1970s Europe opened the gates, releasing what Caldwell calls 'network power', and what I call the 'immigration dynamic'. Every immigrant makes his own personal decision to immigrate, but together with all the other immigrants making that same decision, he makes up a formidable movement. As time went by and Europe realized what was happening, the arguments used by its politicians and policy makers also changed accordingly. Caldwell brings the different arguments used to explain why immigration is good and shows their internal contradictions.

Caldwell points out that the US had managed to integrate its immigrants better than Europe, though there are several difference: the US did not have to deal with mass immigration of a completely different culture (Muslim immigration) and the US forces the immigrants to integrate. In fact, Caldwell says that Europe's immigration problem is more similar to the race problem in the US. The Muslim culture in Europe and the Black culture in the US are 'adversary cultures' - built on distrust towards the dominant culture. When it comes to the Muslims their 'adversity' can easily slip into dangerous territory. There is a thin line between sedition and acceptable protest.

He does not see race as an issue in Europe, but I think that he really missed the point here. I agree with him that the best comparison is to the race problem in the US, but this is not because Europe's problem is racism. It's ethnicism.

Europe is made up of ethnic nation states. The ethnicity of the US, on the other hand, is its political system. An immigrant to the US can accept his new 'founding fathers', though he has no blood ties to the men who founded the nation. An immigrant in Denmark, on the other hand, can't become a descendant of the Vikings based on wish alone, and at this point in time, this wish barely exists. Assimilation wise, Islam is much more similar to the US. It is not ethnically based. A European convert to Islam can aspire to live according to the lifestyle of the prophet, and not feel that he's pretending to be somebody he really is not.


Assimilation

Caldwell uses the terms 'integration' and 'assimilation' interchangeably, but they are not really the same. In fact an 'issue' by many Muslims today is that they are willing to integrate but not to assimilate. Assimilating means losing your ethnic identity while integrating means keeping your own identity but being a part of the society. This could mean anything from being able to function in society to accepting the social norms. As Caldwell points out, some Europeans are fine with just 'demanding' that immigrants keep the local law.

Even if the Muslims of Europe might be integrated, they are far from assimilated. Caldwell points out that in France, for example, children of Italian or Polish immigrants were not considered 'second generation', but rather 'French'. I think the reason for that is simple. In her book "Generous Betrayal", Norwegian anthropologist Unni Wikan quotes the American sociologist Nathan Glazer who says that inter-ethnic marriage is the last step of assimilation. It marks the highest degree of social acceptance. I think it's more than that. I think that it is the only way to assimilate into a culture, into an ethnicity. Inter-ethnic marriage is a serious problem for today's Jewry for exactly this reason. It is not the 'last step' of assimilation. It is assimilation.

The Italian and Polish immigrants to France assimilated. Their children (or grandchildren) were already ethnically French. Take Sarkozy as an example: the son of an Hungarian father and French mother - he's French as can be. Though Muslim assimilation in France is relatively high compared to other European Muslims, it is still very low. Most Muslims marry Muslims from abroad or fellow Muslim immigrants, usually from the same ethnic background. Only a few would marry a European. And even among those who do marry Europeans, not all assimilate. There are cases where the European partner has decided to assimilate into the Muslim ethnicity instead.

'Invented' identities are one way for non-Europeans to integrate. For example, while most of the 'ethnic' English see themselves as 'English', most of the minorities see themselves as 'British'. The EU is a way for immigrants to become Europeans, even if they can't join the 'ethnic' natives. the problem is that you can call yourself 'European', but it doesn't leave you with any real identity.

In any case, Caldwell speaks of the lack of integration. Muslims in Europe don't think highly of European values. Since many Europeans have no idea what their values are, and have been quiet busy tearing those values down for the past few decades, that is not really surprising.

The second generation is de-assimilating and turning to its 'native' culture - Islam. In fact, this is a simplification. In many cases the 'native' culture is a folk Islam. The European youth are rejecting that as well, and turning to Arab Islam or multinational Islam, as a way of finding an identity. Caldwell speaks of the second generation assimilating into a globalized Islam, driven by what they see as the suffering of Muslims around the world.

Muslims accuse the West of colonization, but in many respects, this is exactly what the Muslim immigrants are doing today to the West: They are coming to Europe in order to enjoy the benefits European society offers, but they have no intention to assimilate into the local culture.


Religious Reform

The world today is experiencing religious renewal, a renewal which is barely felt in Europe. Caldwell says that Europeans who do want to feel that renewal are more likely to choose Islam over Christianity. He ignores the data that he himself brings, that Christianity is experiencing a revival of sorts in Europe as well.

Caldwell rejects the notion that Christianity developed into today's enlightened version on its own. He says that European secularism was set up in order to combat Christianity. Whatever space was given to religion in the public sphere, it was a concession given in return for Christianity leaving the rest to the secular state.

Islam is being protected from the very process which developed Christianity. It is being protected from ridicule, from criticism, from academic study. Caldwell is talking about Europe, but I don't really see enough (or any) wish in the Muslim world to 'attack' Islam. Even if Islam would face criticism in the West, can it really change as long as it remains the same in Muslim dominated countries? I really don't know.

Caldwell is very dismissive of the idea of moderate Islam and moderate Muslims. Moderate Islam, at the moment, is a hope, not a fact. He says that the level of moderation of Muslims actually depends on their view of politics, rather than view of Islam.

Caldwell writes what I've said many times: Tariq Ramadan, who's considered a moderate Muslim, doesn't practice 'taqiya', he says exactly what he means. It is the Europeans (or the West), who prefer to interpret what he means in the most moderate way possible. Ramadan speaks of 'war', of 'resistance'. It is the Europeans who decide to understand this as 'peaceful reform'.

Ramadan speaks of 'Jihad' as a 'spiritual effort', but as his grandfather al-Banna - whom Ramadan quotes as an influence - says that Jihad of the mind and Jihad of the sword are two sides of the same coin. According to Caldwell, Tariq Ramadan and Pim Fortuyn both saw Islam in the same way - a religious value system which can easily overwhelm Europe. They just didn't agree on whether that's a good thing.

Caldwell is also critical of the idea that Islam is never a problem. What sort of religion requires expertise so as not to become dangerous? Caldwell dismissively says that there's no such thing as 'moderate protestants'. That is true, but there are 'fundamentalist protestants'. This brings up another point: by saying 'moderate Muslims', people are acknowledging that 'Islam', in itself, is not 'moderate'.


'Minority protectionism'

Caldwell speaks out against the laws designed to prevent Holocaust denial - once one group was specially 'protected', everybody else wanted in as well, if only to prove that they were just as important. This directly led to today's situation, where people can not voice their opinions on the issues of the day for fear of being sued.

As an aside, Europe's law to 'protect' the memory of the Holocaust did nothing to protect its victims. The Muslims today are cast as the 'new Jews' and the Jews as the 'new Nazis'. In France, Jewish students refuse to go to school since they're afraid of the jeers they'll hear during history lessons. Teaching the Holocaust is not helping its victims, and the Muslims seem to be unaware that they're the prime beneficiaries of Europe's guilt over the Holocaust. Instead we see what French philosopher Finkielkraut predicted: anti-racism is now becoming a source of violence.

After WWII nationalism became passe in Europe. However, the immigrants who soon started coming were usually encouraged to be proud of theirs. Caldwell theorizes that since Europeans could not embrace their own nationalism, they embraced that of others, and in particular that of the Palestinians. It's an interesting idea, though it seems to me that it was more a way of channeling repressed antisemitism than repressed nationalism.

Multiculturalism wasn't only an issue of repressed nationalism, it was/is also an issue of processing European guilt feelings over colonization. The only problem? Immigrants are flooding into all of Europe, not only to former colonial powers. The Brits might feel guilty for their escapades in South-East Asia, but the Swedes don't owe the Palestinians anything. And though the colonial powers might feel they owe the people of their former colonies, what do the Italian owe the Albanians, Egyptians or Moroccans? Or the Dutch to the Moroccans and Turks?


Mosques and sexual freedom

According to Caldwell there are two basic issues where the Europeans do say 'stop'. One is mosques. When Muslims build mosques, Europeans have to accept the fact that Islam is going to stay, and that's a very difficult thing for them to do. It had taken a few decades just to realize that the 'temporary' workers don't intend to go back.

Resistance to mosques is mostly a popular sentiment, not usually supported by the politicians. There is one 'value' supported even by the most multicultural European politician, and that's everything having to do with sexual freedom, whether it's the veil, or honor killings, or homosexuality. It's no coincidence that the one thing that caused the Norwegian government to threatened the Islamic Council of Norway with withdrawing subsidies was their refusal to condemn the death sentence for homosexuals.

The violence Muslim women face in order to make them comply with the 'norm' is not simple violence. In such cases violence makes law. One honor murder can cause thousands of women to comply with the 'honor' norms.

Caldwell points out that male dominated societies lay down codes of virginity because they are hard to live by. This enables the men to use women sexually without feeling guilty. They are raped/sexually abused etc because they are sluts, and they are sluts because they have been defined so by men. Again, I think Caldwell misses a basic point. There are many religious societies where virginity is prized. It is the societies where only female virginity is prized that things can turn really ugly for women.

Now the question is: is this Islam? Islam (unlike Christianity) is not totally at odds with the West's sexual practice of the day, and in Europe Islam can actually serve as a way out of this sexist culture. As I wrote above, young European Muslims are leaving their parents' cultures and assimilating into globalized Islam. One reason to do this is to escape their parent's notions of family honor and the place of women in society.

Sexual freedom is a highly regarded value in Europe, but Europeans sometimes have trouble putting their finger on what is really bothering them. Take the headscarf. Why can't women decide on their own what to wear? Are you really going to force a woman to be sexually free? For some reason, when it comes to sexual freedom, Europeans seem willing to sacrifice other liberal values.

Caldwell says that Europe should learn from the experience of Ottoman empire. The multi-ethnic and multicultural Ottoman empire was torn apart by Europeans coming to 'save' their brethren. I don't know if Caldwell intended to take things this far, but one could say that the same thing is happening in Europe today. The Muslim world is demanding rights for its Muslim brethren in the West, and threatening with sanctions if there's no compliance.

More on Caldwell:

* Hirsi Ali: Europe surrendered to Islam
* Quote: Reflections on the Revolution in Europe
* Quote: Europe is making concessions to Islam
* Christopher Caldwell on Fox News

Denmark: Marked differences between immigrant and Danish children

Denmark: Marked differences between immigrant and Danish children


A study in Denmark of 11 year olds shows that there are big differences between Danish children and immigrant children.

Mette Deding of SFI says she was surprised that there were so many differences. She would have expected that the groups of children would be more similar.

In general, immigrant families are bigger and have less money. The parents are less educated and more often on unemployment and welfare. The mothers suffer more often from fear, depression and fatigue. More fathers have sat in prison. But in some areas the immigrant children do better than their Danish counterparts. They're more likely to want to go to school.

Two thirds of Danish boys say that it's good or really good to go to school, compared to close to 90% of immigrant girls who say they're very glad to go to school.

The study doesn't say, however, what makes it so much fun to go to school: the teachers, subjects or fellow students. But, says Mette Deding, it might mean that it's only in the higher classes, when there are greater demands, that things go wrong.

Danish children go more often to organized after-school activities such as football, scouts, riding or dance classes. Immigrant girls in particular don't go to organized after-school activities.

Danish children often invite friends home, while immigrant children prefer to meet their friends elsewhere. The researchers say this is important for their socializing in Danish society.

Mette Deding says that by going home with friends the children learn of life in other families. It's an important part of the child's upbringing and their socializing, and immigrant children don't get it to the same degree. The same happens in organized after-school activities, where you could socialize and come in contact with an important part of Danish society.

The study also shows that more immigrant children live in a core family with both a father and mother. Among Danish families it's more widespread that the children live with their mother's new husband.


Source: Kristeligt Dagblad (Danish)

Belgium: Third of Moroccans feel Muslim, 7% Belgian

Belgium: Third of Moroccans feel Muslim, 7% Belgian

Update: See here for more study results: Belgium: Who are the Belgian Moroccans?


More than a third of Moroccans in Belgium feel Muslim first, barely 7% identify with the Belgian nationality. Nevertheless, the majority is Belgian, according to a study by the King Baudouin Foundation, reports Belgian newspaper Le Soir. In collaboration with the King Baudouin Foundation, the University of Rabat questioned 400 people from the Moroccan community in Belgium.

Just a third of respondents (31.7%) have a work contract and a fifth (21%) receive unemployment benefits. The respondents invoke discrimination in order to explain their difficult integration into the work-market.

Women are less employed than men (38.3% compared to 55.4%). The number of inactive women, for family or other reasons, is 62%. More than half (53%) of the Belgian Moroccans interviewed live below the poverty line, particularly in Wallonia.

Belgian Moroccans prefer a non-mixed marriage. More than half of the respondents thinks it's good to have somebody come from their homeland for a marriage. 62% are against a marriage of a Muslim woman with a non-Muslims. Just 45% disapprove of the reverse.

Source: HLN (Dutch)

Netherlands: Study of Muslim youth

For many young Muslims religion is not something that seriously engages them in daily life. They feel Muslim, show themselves as such by wearing a headscarf for example and keeping Ramadan, and think the laws of Islam are important. But they don't observe them strictly, certainly not if they are yet young.

That is one of the trends among young Moroccans, Turks and Muslim Surinamese, described in Geloof en Geluk (Faith and Happiness), a study about tradition and renewal among young Muslims by the Institute for Multicultural Development FORUM.

Researchers of the University of Amsterdam (UvA) interviewed 32 'key figures' from Amsterdam (students, middle school students and working youth, educators, social workers, neighborhood agents and volunteers in the mosque). Through their network they got insight into the world of about 900 young Muslims 15-29 years old.

The youth emphasized more and more strongly that they, besides being Muslims, are Dutch citizens. They talked easily about mutual differences in religious notions, although it isn't appreciated if other Muslims openly talk against Islam.

(Click to enlarge)

Young Muslims could appreciate fellow youth who took religion seriously, provided that they also followed the religious laws strictly. Korf: "The feeling that you have with a nun; you respect them, but you shouldn't think of it yourself."

The orthodox colleagues shouldn't be intrusive. Dirk Korf: "Most young Muslims really like Western freedoms." They must not radicalize or preach violence. Support for such youth has dropped in recent years, the researchers observe. Particularly because radical fanatics stand in the way of faith and happiness for young Muslims.

'Faith and happiness' is a follow up study to 'Van Vasten tot Feesten' (From fasts to holidays, 2007), that studied particularly trends among highly educated Muslim youth in the Netherlands and ''Van Allah tot Prada' (From Allah to Prada, 2006), which studied the life of all Muslim youth. 'Faith and happiness' concentrated on the lower educated Muslim youth (MBO, vocational education). Besides the study of key figures, 347 Muslim students (from ROCs in Amsterdam and The Hague) answered a questionnaire. The age of ROC students is 16-20 [ROC gives adult vocational training]. These youth adhere more to the laws of religion than students and adolescents.

Of the ROC students, 85% agreed with the following statement: "Muslim means for me particularly that I keep the laws of the faith." 12.5% of ROC students visits mosques often, 15% regularly and most (67%) goes now and then to rarely, a small group never.

Less than half (42%) prays often, 17% regularly, 33% now and then to raraely and 9% never. In comparison with ROC students, twice as many students never go to a mosque, and twice as many never pray. At the same time, almost half of ROC students think it's more important to be a good man than to precisely follow the religious laws.

Dirk Korf, UvA researcher: "Saying that you think the religious laws are important is yet somewhat different than also actually following them. Praying five times a day is one law. But also doing it is a second. If they're in the tram or apprenticing, prayer loses. They do say often that later, when they're older, they will keep the laws."

A process of renewals and individualizing is visible particularly among highly educated adolescents: they more often live independently and less often leave home only when they get married. Notions of marriage are changing, youth more often think they should be able to choose their own partner. They also think differently about emancipation: many youth think that married women should be able to continue working. Girls lead, particularly Turks. Boys don't escape growing as well, though they stay more traditional in their attitudes, particularly Turkish boys. "The Turkish boys and Turkish girls will yet have trouble when they'll marry," says UvA researcher Dirk Korf.

Because Muslim youth prefer marrying somebody from their own group. 67% of ROC students think it's more important that their future partner have the same ethnicity as their own, almost 25% say it doesn't matter so much and 10% think it's not important at all.

For most ROC students it's important that their future partner be Muslim (91%). Barely 3% think it's not important. 80% of ROC students think their children shouldn't decide on their own whether to be Muslim or not, 10% think the children should decide and 10% are in between.

Resarcher Marije Wouters, who administered the ROC questionnaire, thought the youth were markedly decent youth. Also the Moroccon youth, who think they appear too often negatively in the news due to a group of trouble makers. Wouters: ""They all have black jackets with colored collars, shaved necks and black cap on their heads, they look a bit like loitering youth. but they fill in the questionnaire seriously and say 'please ma'am'.

And most are (very) optimistic (73%) about their future, which they see in the Netherlands. On average the ROC students estimate their chances of living in the Netherlands in five years at 82%. Wouters: "After the MBO they want to go further with an HBO education, have great expectations of life and they will go do it."

Source: NRC, FORUM (Dutch)

Europe: Attitudes towards Muslims

The German Marshall Fund published a joint American-European survey on immigration. The survey checked how different nations view nationality and immigration.

The study and all the data are available in various languages on the Transatlantic Trends site.

The following are the study conclusions regarding Muslims.


Views about Muslim culture are nuanced in all countries


Respondents were asked to agree or disagree with the following two statements: “Muslim immigrants have a lot to offer your country’s culture,” and “Western European (or American) and Muslim ways of life are irreconcilable.”



click to enlarge

Examining the answers to both questions, a nuanced perception of Muslim immigrants emerges. Overall, majorities of American and French respondents were the most optimistic about the cultural influence of Muslim immigrants and the reconcilability of Western and Muslim ways of life. A majority (52%) in the United Kingdom also thought that Muslims have a lot to offer British culture.


German, Dutch, and Italian responses were some of the most complex; in each of those countries, it was not uncommon for a respondent to a) agree that Muslims have a lot to
offer their culture, but b) indicate that their ways of life are irreconcilable.


Americans and Europeans agree that Muslim immigrants want to integrate


A strong majority of Americans (60%) and a plurality of Europeans (47%) agreed that Muslims coming to their countries want to integrate. However, Europeans were aware that integration has not been easy, especially for young, often second-generation Muslims. Forty-nine percent of Europeans thought that Muslim youth are frustrated by their economic situation. The strongest examples of this view were in France (64%) and Germany (60%).


Social contact with immigrants affects attitudes towards Muslims


In all countries surveyed, except Poland (see Country Profile box), a majority of respondents had friends or colleagues who came from other countries. Depending on the frequency of their social contacts with immigrants, people entertained different views regarding the compatibility of Muslim and Western cultures. On both sides of the Atlantic, those who have several friends who come from other countries tended to be more optimistic about the reconcilability
of cultures.


click to enlarge

Germany: Muslims religious and tolerant

Germany's Muslims are pious and yet more tolerant than most assume, a new study has found. Its authors are urging authorities to draw the country's Muslim children away from Koran schools by offering public religious instruction.


Dr. Martin Rieger of the Bertelman Stiftung thinks Muslim children should have their own religion classes. Rieger was the director of the study "Muslim Religiosity in Germany," which was provided to SPIEGEL ONLINE ahead of its scheduled publication on Friday.

 
The study reveals that 90 percent of Muslims define themselves as religous. In contrast a separate survey by the nonprofit German think tank found that only 70 percent of the entire population admitted to being religous. "We need to get the younger Muslims out of the Koran schools," Rieger urges, "and offer them professionally taught classes on Islam."
 
 
(..)
 
 
According to the report, Sunni Muslims living in Germany are religious to an above-average degree; 92 percent identify themselves as being religious. Among Shiites in Germany, that number lies at 90 percent, and it is 77 percent for members of the Alevite community. "Islam in Germany is not a unified block," Rieger says. "It's very multifaceted."


Rieger also finds it "surprising" that religion only has a major influence on the political stance of a small group of Muslims. The study found that only 16 percent of the Muslims surveyed said that their faith had an effect on their political attitudes and that two-thirds of them would say no to having their own Islamic political party.

 
Rieger also makes a point of stressing the high degree of tolerance shown by Muslims in Germany. Sixty-seven percent said that they agreed that every religion has a "core of truth," and 86 percent said that people should have "an open mind to all religions." "This value is equally high for all of the groups studied," Rieger says, "regardless of gender, age, denomination or ancestry."
 
 
The Bertelsmann study also speaks about German Muslims having a "rather pragmatic approach" to Islam. Over half of those surveyed were against the wearing of headscarves, while only 33 percent are for it. "However, these results do not mean that the headscarf will really be worn," says Ulusoy. From what he has learned, it's really more of an issue of "reconciling religiosity with everyday life." For Ulusoy, it's also a sign that Muslims are not sealing themselves off from society.
 
Source: Spiegel (English)

Brussels: Study urges for more tolerance

A study by the Institute for European Studies at VUB in cooperation with the Centre for Peace and Conflict Studies of Wayne State University in Detroit was published Thursday by Richard Lewis and Hannelore Goeman, concluding that more tolerance is needed in order to encourage integration.

Seeing that the Muslim population of Detroit, with 300,000 or 7.5% of the population is the largest urban concentration of Muslims in the US, the study claims that several parallels can be drawn with the situation in Brussels, which has 170,000 Muslims or 17% of the population and Brussels can even learn a lot from the tolerant approach of the Americans and Canadians.

The conclusions of the researchers are based on a study trip of to the American and Canadian Midwest in March and on the conclusions of a team of experts from Brussels and Detroit who are active on the local level in various policy areas connected to the integration of immigrants (and in specific of Muslims).  The researchers also visited the nearest Canadian city: Windsor, Ontario.

Muslims in Detroit appear to have a much smoother upwards mobility than their coreligionists in Brussels.  American Muslims often immigrate with a higher education level, and many come from the Middle East, while Muslims immigrants in Brussels are often from poorer, rural areas in North Africa and Turkey.

But another key to success according to the researchers is clearly the respect and tolerance with which they are treated in their new country.  Muslims in America therefore get the feeling faster that they have an in interest in engaging in society, and are therefore more loyal towards their new country.

On the basis of the study the researchers ask for three things which are very sensitive in Belgium.  They ask for full tolerance of the headscarf - an issue which in Detroit has never caused a fuss.  According to the researchers this leads to a more tolerant mentality which is much needed for successful integration.

Additionally they ask for bilingual education, that combines the new language with the mother-tongue of the children who have just arrived in the country.  After about a year they can switch over to the traditional, one-language form of education.  The system had been applied successfully for years in Canada and now also in Detroit.

Finally the researchers ask for more tolerance for the cultural and religious needs of Muslims, for example by providing them with a separate prayer area at work.

The report includes also a number of practical recommendations such as directly consulting the Muslim communities, attention to "interculturalism" in the training of teachers and social workers, the emphasis of the economical and cultural contribution of Muslims, for example with a museum, and investing in the neighborhoods in order to prevent decline.

Source: De Morgen (Dutch)