UK: Why Sharia is better

The Independent explains why Sharia law is much better than British law. However, Hibah Khan's problem starts with the fact that British courts recognize her Sharia marriage in Pakistan. They would also recognize her divorce in Pakistan, but for some reason she prefers getting a divorce in a British Sharia court, apparently without the consent of both sides.


She bring quite a few problems with her Sharia marriage, but she explains it all away as something that is 'un-Islamic' and anti-Sharia, a philosophy she does not apply to anything the British do. As for her previous marriage - it was annulled by a Sharia court. Was it ever registered in Britain? She doesn't say, and the Independent doesn't ask.



When Hibah Khan wanted a divorce, she turned to a sharia court. Her case would have concluded swiftly and happily – if the ruling had been allowed to stand...


Tucked away in Leyton, east London, is Britain's oldest sharia court. Entirely innocuous, there are no signs promoting its presence, nor anything in its façade to suggest the gravity of the decisions made within its four walls. Once a corner-shop, and haphazardly arranged into an office space with the help of temporary partitions, it is now the site of hundreds of judgments each month based on the requirements of Islamic law. Yet, in the 25 years since its inception, it has not presided over any of the stereotypical cases associated with sharia law – not one hand has been cut off, norfornicator flogged. Rather more prosaically, penal law is never addressed – the fatwas (judgments) all concern personal issues such as divorce, financial arbitration, family disputes and inheritances.


It is here that Hibah Khan, 38, is currently trying to divorce her husband. She was brought up in England and her parents instilled in her both western and Islamic values. She met her husband on a holiday in Pakistan. "He was good-looking, educated – a doctor – and we had similar backgrounds," she says. "We liked each other and kept in touch." A year later, in late 1990, they got married in Pakistan. "I decided that following our wedding I would move there," she says. "I was in love, excited, and although I was working as an accountant in London I wanted a change; I was pretty naive."


The differences began to surface immediately. On the wedding day itself, the groom's family shocked Khan by demanding a dowry. "In Islam, the groom is meant to give a gift to the bride," she says. Although she had been married before, at the age of 21, she'd never lived with her then-husband and the marriage was annulled through a sharia court. "My new husband had said that he didn't mind about me being divorced, but once we were married it was clear he thought my family and I should be very grateful that he had married me. That really shocked me. I was very independent, living and working in London, and then there I was, living in a village to please my in-laws."


The couple started arguing and not long after the wedding, Khan's husband declared he was going to take a second wife. "Again, people think this is Islamic," says Khan, "but they don't know that there is small print. In Islam, you should have one wife, but if you have a second, you have to live with her equally and divide your earnings equally. What man can do that?" Her husband then had an affair. "I forgave him because I'd just given birth to our first child. The harder I tried, the more he thought I was desperate to be married to him." Then Khan became pregnant with her second child. "I was on the verge of a nervous breakdown," she says, "So I returned to England and started seeking a divorce."


The court in Leyton where Khan's divorce is now being heard is one of dozens, also known as councils, across Britain. The judgments made there are informed by the teachings of the Koran, but have no basis in British law; modern British Muslims can therefore find themselves working within a legal system that they feel does not fully understand the rigours of their faith. Much in the way a Jewish couple will seek a religious divorce from the Beth Din court, some Muslims turn to sharia for an Islamic divorce.


It is a far cry from the raging debate prompted by the comments from the Archbishop of Canterbury, Rowan Williams, when he implied in a lecture earlier this month that the adoption of parts of sharia law will be "unavoidable" in this country's legal system.


Faced with outrage and claims that he was opening a door to extremist Islamic punishments and a parallel legal system, Williams insisted he was simply addressing an issue that had to be debated, and that, "Christians and people of other faiths ought to be doing some reflecting together" about the relationship between law and religion. Calls for his resignation quickly ensued – including from two members of the Church of England synod – though the Prime Minister came out in support, praising Williams' "great integrity".


Khan's case illustrates a flaw in the dual-legal system. "Even though my marriage was never registered here, and my husband has never even been to the UK, my solicitor tells me the Islamic marriage certificate is recognised by the British government as legitimate, but the Islamic divorce certificate is not." So Khan now has to seek a divorce through British law as well as the one she is currently seeking through the sharia court.


Ironically, when the row over sharia law first came up in Britain, many people argued it would make life more difficult for women, since it has a poor reputation for upholding women's rights. In Khan's case, the problem seems to be the British court. It sent a petition to Khan's husband and gave him two weeks to answer. They heard nothing. If he was resident in this country, they would send bailiffs to present the petition in person, but because her husband lives in a different country, it is up to Khan to ensure he receives it.


"I have to find someone in Pakistan to send the petition to, and get them to take it to my husband, take a photograph of him, and sign an affidavit. But I don't know where he is. And I'm scared of posting the petition because Pakistan is having elections, and things are a bit unreliable there. The only thing holding me up now is the British court. It's causing so much stress. I don't know where to go, who to ask or why this is happening."


Meanwhile in the sharia court, progress is being made. "I have one more meeting, then in three months I will be a free woman," says Khan. "The thing is, some people practise Islam according to the way their forefathers did. But in Islam the learning is never-ending – you're always finding new ways, always interpreting. In this light, the current argument about sharia law in Britain is a pity: it's sad to see people saying anti-Islamic things when they haven't read what the Archbishop's lecture was about.


"There are laws here which are close to sharia already. Look at the benefit system and disability allowance: that's basically the Prime Minister – the leader – looking after his people. In sharia law, it says the leader of a nation has to look after the people. Whereas, is [Pakistani President Pervez] Musharraf giving benefits to his people? No.


"The sharia council has been brilliant – they've really helped me, and I'm relieved someone out there is listening," she adds. "I respect the laws of this country, but for me, marriage vows are sacred, and being married by Islamic law, having an Islamic marriage, is first and foremost.


"The sharia court is a very important part of the law, and the council is such a help to our Muslim community. People who have a negative attitude say that it is barbaric, but really, it is moderate Muslims, rather than the extremists, who are the ones who turn to it. It has allowed me to have the chance of freedom, to take up teaching, and start being happy with my life again."


Hibah Khan's name has been changed to protect her identity


Crime and punishment: What is sharia law?


Sharia is the body of Islamic religious law based on the Koran, Muhammad's teaching, the actions of his followers, and centuries of precedent.


Liberal Muslims say sharia law is not a static code but is open to interpretation, while more hardline followers claim the laws are eternal and should be followed to the letter.


Penal law is only a small part of sharia. The flogging of drunkards and adulterers and cutting off of thieves' hands is perhaps the
best-known aspect of sharia law to non-Muslims, but most of the laws are concerned with prosaic issues, from financial arbitration to divorce and personal hygiene.


Sharia law is not legally binding in Britain. However, there are a dozen sharia courts in Britain, which operate out of mosques and deliver judgments on personal law, including divorce and financial issues.


Britain's oldest sharia court is in Leyton (judges Abu Saeed and Suhaib Hassan, pictured below). In operation for 25 years, it has Charity Commission status, issues around 10 fatwas (judgments) a day and hears around 50 divorces a month.


Source: The Independent (English)

Sweden: Lack of mother-tongue instruction

Over half of Sweden's municipalities don't offer lessons taught in students' native languages, according to a survey carried out by Swedish Radio. The primary cause is a lack of qualified teachers.


Students with Somali, Roma, or Arabic as their first language are most affected.



Three of four municipalities have also had difficulty recruiting instructors to lead mother-tongue classes.


"We're not going to let ourselves accept such 'excuses' from the municipalities. They must show that they are trying to recruit," said Alf Johansson, a lawyer with the inspection division of the National Agency for Education.


250 of Sweden's 290 municipalities participated in the survey.


Source: The Local (English)

Denmark: Hijab in parliament

The Danish Parliament's presidency is in a state of alert in case Asmaa Abdol-Hamid will be called in to replace Johanne Schmidt-Nielsen. The representative of the Danish People's Party's (DPP) in the presidency, Søren Espersen, threatened to stop Abdol-Hamid from coming in with her headscarf if he's chairing the session.

The presidency had planned a seminar in April where the question will be discussed and new guidelines prepared. However, Espersen had said that he will do everything to forbid any form of head covering in the parliament hall. He wants to make it clear to Abdol-Hamid that if he's chairing the session when she comes in, she will either take off her headscarf or leave. He says it's not a discussion club, though she could of course complain to the presidency afterwards about the decision. He says he hopes it won't be realistic before the presidency discusses the issue.

Asmaa Abdol Hamid is currently the first replacement for Johanne Schmidt-Nielsen for the Red-Green Alliance. The party normally makes good use of deputies, so it's not improbably that Abdol-Hamid will enter the parliamentary hall.

In contrast to those elected, according to the parliament's uniform regulation employees are allowed to go with a head covering for religious reasons, but it must be issues by the parliament, so that it would fit in with the rest of the uniform.

Abdol-Hamid says that she thinks Espersen's threat is undemocratic. Denmark is a democratic country with a democratic leadership. If the DPP has problems with the values in Denmark they must find another place. It should be a place that is more similar to them - maybe a place in the Middle East.

She says she's doesn't believe she will be kicked out of Parliament. There's a stable, live democracy and the DPP should learn that. The Danes talk and the Danes decide - not the DPP or Søren Espersen. We can't have them making specific laws. She thinks it's very dictatorial and doesn't belong in a democracy. We will fight all undemocratic forces in our society.

She says she would like to see the politicians who came out fighting against undemocratic forces in society such as Hizb ut-Tahrir also stand up and say that Espersen's attitude isn't acceptable.

Abdol-Hamid's party, the Red Green Alliance, had requested clarification regarding the parliament's rules about head covering.

Per Clausen, deputy chairman, says they think Espersen's demand is against the rule and expect the Parliament's chairman to abide by the rules and not to make up their own rules. It's their clear understanding that according to the current regulations it's not possible to prevent a parliament member from wearing a headscarf.

Sources :Politiken 1, 2, 3 (Danish)

See also: Denmark: Can a parliament member wear hijab, Denmark: When the media has no story

Netherlands: Woman in Burqini kicked out of pool

A 26 year old woman was kicked out of a pool in Zwolle (Netherlands) on Thursday because she was wearing a burqini. The Muslim women, Liselotte Buitelaar, was in the water just five minutes playing with her two year old son, Illias, when she was told that there were complaints about her clothing.

Manager of the public pool, Hans Meijer, says that their regular public thinks it objectionable and that they need to take that into account. He says that they do the same for obese people and that they have separate hours for this groups so that they can swim with each other. Zwolle is not open yet to burqinis and he has to take that into account.

Alderman Janco Cnossen says that there's no policy that forbids wearing a burqini. The responsibility for allowing it is therefore up to the management of the pool. He had understood that they don't consider it swim-clothing. If Buitelaar will want to follow the example of other Muslims, then the alderman will discuss the issue with the pool management.

After complaints about a burkini in Almelo - where the woman could continue swimming in the end - the cabinet had says that a burqini was regular swimming wear. State Secretary Jet Bussemaker (Health and Sports) had said that it's not an Islamization of the sport, but really a form of integration.

Buitelaar, who converted six years ago, is disappointed. She says she didn't do it in order to provoke, but she does want to defend the burqini. She can imagine that people who had never seen such a swimsuit will think it's strange. In another pool she had gotten comments about her wearing clothing. She's happy with such reactions because then she can explain that it's just a larger swimsuit of real swimsuit material. It's very light and completely different from regular clothing.

The burqini was invented in Australia and has been available in the Netherlands since last year. the Burka is a black robe that only leaves the eyes uncovered, but the burqini is available in every vivid color.

Woortman Sportswear in Meppel has had the exclusive rights for the distribution of the swimsuit in Europe and North Africa since Novembers. The demand is so high that the company is looking for larger space. According to the owner, they had not expected that.

Source: Dagblad van het Noorden (Dutch)

See also: Netherlands: Burkini good for integration, Almelo: A fuss about a burkini, Temse: Veiled women kicked out of pool

Netherlands: Emigration increasing

Emigration from the Netherlands is now at a historic high. 132,470 residents left the country in 2006, according to a study of the Netherlands Interdisciplinary Demographic Institute (NIDI), 'Away from the Netherlands, immigration at the beginning of the 21st century'.

The top reason for leaving the Netherlands is the lack of room and tranquility and social problems through pollution, crime and the multicultural society.

The number of people who emigrated has gone up by 67% since 2000. About two thirds are of immigrant origin (about 88,000) and a third are ethnic Dutch (about 44,000). The emigrants are especially young, single men who make a good living.

Source: AD (Dutch)

See also: Netherlands: Third of immigrant youth want to leave, Netherlands: Back to Turkey, Denmark: 25% of immigrant youth want to emigrate

Drammen: Church sold to Turkish community

The Adventist Church in Drammen hopes that the sale of the church to a Muslim community can have consequences for Christians in Muslim countries.

Drammens Tidende wrote Tuesday that the Turkish community in Drammen had bought the Adventist Church in Bragernes in Drammen and will turn it into a mosque. The church was sold for 7.2 million kroner.

Leo Swenson, chairman of the congregation, says that the Adventists have always been engaged with protecting freedom. Working for freedom of religion assumes generation in meeting with other religions. They show this generosity in practice through this sale.

Tor Tjeransen, head of the Seven Day Adventists in Norway points out that many Christians experience difficulties in Turkey. In a press release he expressed the hope that the Turkish community will communicate with its coreligionists in the homeland and tell them about this buy.

Tjeransen says that they want this will be the basis for Christians who wish to buy property and establish churches in a Muslim country to be met with respect, understanding and freedom.

The Adventist community is a protestant community with about 5,000 members in Norway. The Adventist church in Drammen will now build in a new church in Nedre Eiker together with the Adventist Church of Hokksund.

The Turkish congregations is one of the biggest Muslim communities in Drammen, with about 1,000 members.

Orhan Al, head of the Turkish community, says he doesn't want to comment on the sale, but he has formerly told Drammens Tidende that it's not relevant to have a call to prayer in the center of Drammen.

Source: Drammens Tidende (Norwegian)

See also: Drammen: Need for accounting of money going to immigrants

Nørrebro: Police changing tactics

The Copenhagen Police will be restricting itself now in the Nørrebro district. When looking for illegal weapons canine patrols and groups of agents will no longer be used to search people. According to an e-mail that TV 2 News got hold of, this is due to the fear of provoking the youth further.

Claus Olsen, Vice police inspector in the Copenhagen Police, writes to his colleagues that the consequences of their resolute interventions have brought about that group and canine patrols function as a red flag for the youth. Therefore patrols of the emergency department and canine patrols will until further notice not conduct searches in the area around Blågårds Plads and Folkets Park.

He writes that he understands the frustrations that this can cause in connection to the police work that is conducted in the area now.

The head of the Copenhagen Police, Hanne Bech Hansen, says the mail is improperly formulated and gives the impression that the police are running away, which is not what they're doing. She says that they do what they should with the necessary resources, and they don't speculate about whether it hurts anybody.

According to police assistant Palle Andersen, if previously most agents were from the emergency department in large groups, now the job will be done mostly by local officers. This will make room for and strengthen the social workers. The large police cars will stay out of Inner Nørrebro, but be ready if there's any need for them.

The chairman of the Copenhagen Police association, Claus Oxholm, was quoted in one source as being critical but elsewhere he thinks the idea is good. He doesn't think there will be less searches, but it will give the police the possibility to have more cars on the roads, and the local police know better who are the local criminals.

Peter Skaarup, of the Danish People's party says that they don't think that the police is provoking. They think it's really the youth who are provoking. It's the youth who want to decide what goes on and they shouldn't be allowed to.

Sources: TV2, Nyhedsavisen (Danish)

Bulgaria: Considering religious studies in schools

Bulgaria's population is 80 percent Christian Orthodox, by tradition, and the church has long pressed for reintroducing courses on Christianity, which were part of every school's curriculum prior to communism.


The country also has a Turkish minority of Muslim faith, who represent 10 percent of the population.


Under a bid to promote respect for minority rights, optional studies on Christianity or Islam were actually introduced about a decade ago
though only 14,000 students nationwide follow the course on their respective religion.


But these classes "are attracting less and less interest," said an opponent to the government's plan, Lyutfi Mestan, who is chairman of the parliamentary committee on education and an MP for the Turkish minority party Movement for Rights and Freedoms.


"Instead of teaching tolerance, this type of religious study has divided pupils," he insisted.


Source: AFP (English) h/t Daily Atheist

Belgium: Muslim Executive disbanded

The Belgian Muslim community did not succeed to put together a new full Muslim Executive Friday. The non-profit organization behind the representative body is being disbanded and it's personnel fired, says Minister Of Justice Jo Vandeurzen.

The general gathering of the Muslim Executive had to choose new members. Ten of the 17 executive members had not survived a vote of confidence in October or had resigned on their own. The vote did not take place in the end. "The French speaking Moroccans didn't want to," declares vice-president Hacer Düzgün. "The Turkish community doesn't need this executive since we are well organized and come to a consensus quickly. It's the Moroccan community that can't organize itself well. The older generation is out for power and doesn't realize the importance of the Executive."

The Muslim Executive was in a scandal last year after a judicial investigation into fraud in the organization. The French-speaking vice-president Benjelloul Kissi was arrested in September on suspicion of forgery and abuse of trust. Since October the Executive has been functioning with barley half its members. In February Minister Vandeurzen stopped the subsidies and the Executive is now in debt of more than 200,000 euro.

Vandeurzen "regrets" the outcome and confirms once again the need for a representative body for the whole Muslim community, calling to bridge over the internal difference of opinion.

Source: HLN (Dutch)

See also: Belgium: Muslim Executive subsidies delayed, Belgium: Muslim Executive denies allegations, Belgium: Former Muslim leader held for embezzlement

Belgium: Wife of murder-terrorist suspect denies connection to murders

The wife of Abdelkader Belliraj, the Belgian-Moroccan resident of Evergem who was the leader of a terrorist network dismantled in Morocco, has nothing to do with the six murders her husband is suspected of, says the family's lawyer, Abderrahim Lahlali. The lawyer can only conclude through the media that Abdelkader Belliraj had confessed, but he's waiting for the results of a rogatory committee to Morocco.

Abdelkader Belliraj is suspected by the Moroccan government of having committed six murders in Belgium in 1986-1989. "My clients have been together since 1991. I stress that his wife therefore certainly has nothing to do with the allegations of the events of the late 80s. I can't speak yet about the other accusations against her husband. I haven't been able to see yet any files, but I understand that a rogatory committee will be sent to Morocco. I can just conclude from the reports of the press that Mr. Belliraj had confessed, but I have no further information about it," says Lahlali.

Abdelkader Belliraj's wife is most concerned about the welfare of her three minor children, according to the lawyer. The children go to school in Evergem and Mrs. Belliraj asks the media to leave them in peace.

Source: HLN (Dutch)

See also: Belgium: Terrorist leader committed six murders